All-Star Supergirl

All-Star Supergirl

An untitled 'Supergirl' television show is reportedly being pitched to various networks. Like me I'm sure many fans are excited to hopefully see her alongside the brilliant 'Arrow' and the (if the pilot is an indication) horrendous 'The Flash', but while we wait with nails between our teeth I thought I'd give us something else to run through with a countdown of my top choices to take up the mini skirt of justice as the last daughter of krypton

Editorial Opinion
By Parkerluckpersonified - Sep 11, 2014 08:09 AM EST
Filed Under: Supergirl

There has been a lot of talk recently about the proposed ‘Supergirl’ television series that is being shopped around various networks. It seems a lot of the details are still up in the air (little flying reference in there for you) such as its title, its network and consequently whether it could become part of the Arrowverse alongside the Flash.
Kara is my favourite DC character and I think her New 52 journey has been one of the better ones. The re-telling of her origin was not as good as the Jeph Loebb Superman/ Batman apocalypse version, but it is told in a way that makes it perfect for adaptation on the big or small screen and her subsequent adventures have been funny and emotional in equal measure with a healthy dose of action as well. This groundwork paves the way for a talented actress to come in and make the role her own, so I thought I would (rather prematurely) throw a few names in the hat to fill Kara’s tall red boots.
I have decided to include my top five semi- realistic choices for the character, in other words choices that I think may be interested in a television role rather than big name movie actresses. I have also thrown in a bolter at the end.

5- Amber Heard

Amber made her big screen acting debut in the Friday Night Lights movie but she really caught my eye during the Mixed Martial Arts/ Teen drama fusion movie Never Back Down. In this film she showed her ability to play a character who was smart, confident and sexy but who also had a strong moral compass. She was able to demonstrate a good emotional range and establish good chemistry with her co-star, which will be important for the inevitable love story that will be developed on a tv show.

<img src="/images/users/uploads/51183/Amber heard.jpg" />

Heard is currently in filming for another big screen outing but if it turns out to be anything like her other cracks at film, Drive Angry for example.... she may just fancy some more television parts.

4- Katrina Bowden

Katrina is best known as ‘Cerie’ in tv’s 30 Rock where she showed her considerable acting talents and comic timing which was utilised in her big screen outings for American Pie: The reunion and Movie 43 amongst others. Thor has shown us that when tackling God-like characters humour is important in making them relatable for an audience. Shows like Buffy the Vampire Slayer and Agents of SHIELD have also utilised this technique and it is likely to be used in portraying the “World Breaker” as a relatable human character. Also let’s face it; she’s jaw-dropping beautiful which is always a bonus when casting a Supergirl.

<img src="/images/users/uploads/51183/bowden.jpg" />

Bowden is set to show what she can do in a more dramatised setting in the Spielberg produced Public Morals in 2015 where she will play a prostitute that maintains an air of innocence but if it doesn’t catch-on she may become available and any experience she gains playing a character who tackles dark life situations with innocence can only be a bonus.

3- Emily Kinney

<img src="/images/users/uploads/51183/kinney.jpg" />

The Walking Dead Fan-favourite ‘Beth’ has shown Kinney capable of playing a character who pulls an aura of hope and innocence around with her, even after her world has ended. Despite being in her late 20s Emily is capable of playing a character in her teens of in young adulthood with a level of emotional maturity and strength that would do Kara justice. Kinney shares the otherworldly beauty of Saorise Ronan or Janet Devlin, a ‘Luna Lovegood’ kind of pretty that would be interesting when applied to the last daughter of a dead world.

2- Aimee Teegarden

Another Friday Night Lights alumni Aimee received an Actress of the Year award for her performances in the critically acclaimed television drama. Throughout the show she played the role of an intelligent, confident and powerful young woman trapped in a town she hates. Sound familiar? We watched her deliver performances that were sweet, heartbreaking, funny and uplifting; she really has it all. She even managed to be attractive throughout even with that horrific fringe!

<img src="/images/users/uploads/51183/teegarden.jpg" />

Despite all this Teegarden has failed to break into mainstream movies and since her more recent tv role in Starcrossed (I still haven’t watched it but am keen to do so) is over and done with, this little mound of talent could be primed for a kryptonian make-over (dodgey ‘New 52’ fringe included).

  1. Claudia Lee
Claudia Lee is a diamond in the not-so-rough... in that she’s all smooth and shiny. A performer all her life Lee is a talented musician and more importantly a brilliant dancer (always a great springboard for action/ flight scenes). If you don’t watch the brilliant Hart of Dixie you may well only know her as “The hot dancer who vomits” in Kick Ass 2; If you are a fan of the show thought you will see that she possesses many of the talents of those above rolled into one. Her comic timing is fantastic and she tackles her role of ‘Magnolia’ with an innocence and naivety that makes an audience love her regardless of what schemes she concocts.

<img src="/images/users/uploads/51183/lee.jpg" />

Claudia is only 18 and so is the perfect age to take on the role. Her recurring part in Hart of Dixie has not stopped her from other projects like Surviving Jack and a couple of big screen outings so one assumes that she could fit Kara into her schedule- plus she is already on the CW so if Supergirl finds a home there she must be in with a chance.

The Bolter: Molly Quinn

Molly has famously played the role before, voicing the character in Superman Unbound. Like many of these actresses Molly is young and has a feeling of that youth and innocence about her. In Castle she portrays a smart, strong moralled pretty girl with a big heart and she does so brilliantly. If DC fancy something a bit different to comic book Kara, then Quinn must be worth a shout.

<img src="/images/users/uploads/51183/quinn.jpg" />

Disclaimer: I in no way advocate the dying of Molly Quinn’s hair.
Did You Know: SUPERGIRL Villain Matthias Schoenaerts Was In Line To Play BATMAN In The DCEU
Related:

Did You Know: SUPERGIRL Villain Matthias Schoenaerts Was In Line To Play BATMAN In The DCEU

James Gunn Addresses Internet Rumors - Is He Referring To Recent SUPERGIRL Report?
Recommended For You:

James Gunn Addresses Internet Rumors - Is He Referring To Recent SUPERGIRL Report?

DISCLAIMER: ComicBookMovie.com is protected under the DMCA (Digital Millenium Copyright Act) and... [MORE]

ComicBookMovie.com, and/or the user who contributed this post, may earn commissions or revenue through clicks or purchases made through any third-party links contained within the content above.

EhMaybeSays
EhMaybeSays - 9/11/2014, 8:56 AM
Try adding pics.
Alphadog
Alphadog - 9/11/2014, 9:48 AM
@ComicBookConnections The pilot was horrendous. It had a terrible script (plot, dialogue, characters, etc...) and acting.
Alphadog
Alphadog - 9/11/2014, 1:28 PM
@ComicBookConnections You called my response laughable. That's ironic. I like your sense of humor. The acting was terrible. Not only were the actors annoying (if people thought that Skye was annoying than they must hate the supporting cast of the Flash, the jokes are stupid unfunny and also annoying and the actors deliver them in the worst possible way). The emotional moments weren't scripted very well but they were acted and directed even worse. There was no chemistry between the cast and like most new actors I've seen these days the young stars just have a really high pitched voice. Why is that. This isn't acting exactly but they can control it a bit so they shouldn't be like that. The script was terrible because of the jokes, because the characters weren't interesting and the drama was written badly and most of it should've been left for later on cus like you said, they had a lot of things to do, still. They stole so many things from other places. Probably even more than Arrow did at first. The plot was not only formulaic but also not compelling. The characters were written very badly. I believe I've said this already but I really have to stress it. Who talks like Vibe? They we're talking about how cool it was when it was nothing like it. Killer Frost was more acceptable but even she wasn't good. They made her a cold bitch that is revealed to have a tragedy in her life. Like that made her interesting. We've seen those things already and she wasn't made well enough that it would still be cool. They were both throaway characters. Arrow had some of these things (not all of them, just some) but it improved. This will also improve probably but they'll still keep the style and it's a terrible style. I'm sure you'll see all this stuff eventually. They're going to keep the series mostly like this and you will turn over.
Alphadog
Alphadog - 9/11/2014, 1:31 PM
I'm not suprised that a pilot had a bad plot or that the characters weren't compelling yet but the writing and the acting established the core of the characters and the style of the show and they won't change far enough for it to disappear and that's the massive problem.
Dingbat
Dingbat - 9/11/2014, 1:52 PM
Supergirl's rightful place is on film. Cast a relatively unknown actress with a slightly exotic look.

ScottMontgomery
ScottMontgomery - 9/11/2014, 7:26 PM
@ComicBookConnections I agree with @Alphadog. All of the superhero tv shows have been terrible so far... I don't understand why people love mediocre shows like Arrow.
ScottMontgomery
ScottMontgomery - 9/11/2014, 7:26 PM
Wait I actually did like the pilot for Constantine.
MightyZeus
MightyZeus - 9/12/2014, 2:48 AM
No really a fan of Supergirl but it's not suited towards me. The television show better make her interesting and the effects to show case her abilities should be top notch.
Parkerluckpersonified
Parkerluckpersonified - 9/12/2014, 8:35 AM
I really like Arrow :-)

The Flash was just awful scripting and Gustin was awful as Barry. Also the super powered villain guy was terrible. It's gonna end up like Smallville, which I liked, but with over reliance on CG.
View Recorder