Why The Amazing Spider-Man Wasn't So Amazing

XMan's synopsis of what was good and what was bad about the not so Amazing Amazing Spider-Man.

Review Opinion
By JamesXMan - Jul 09, 2012 02:07 PM EST
Filed Under: Spider-Man
Source: ComicBookMovie.com

Just saw the Amazing Spider-man... here's my ten cents: WARNING Minor Spoilers below

Here's what I wrote down in my notes right after I saw the movie. What's good or better than previous films:

1. The actors Andrew Garfield and Emma Stone are much better actors as Spider-man and his love interest. Tobey Maguire does a terrible job crying in Spider-Man 3 and I couldn't help but laugh. Here at the death scene at end of movie, Andrews tears put a lump in my throat. While we all probably loved the upside down kiss in the rain in Spiderman 1,the passion and chemistry between Emma Stone and Andrew Garfield are believable.. No wonder they became a real couple.

2. Web slinging more real and fun and iconic.

3. The Lizard in half man half Lizard state where you can see the actor Rhys Ifans was great.

4. Dennis Leary as captain Stacy and Sally Struthers as Aunt May were fantastic.

5. While the suit looked pretty crappy before the film came out in behind the scenes stills, it's color and use in movement actually was ok.. The first suit was cooler but this one was ok too...actually my favorite suit is from spiderman turn off the dark broadway play.. Google that.

What's not so good about the film:

1. The plot line reminded me of something that has been done a million times.. I think in a few of the old batman films.. Mad scientist or crazy villain unleashes something terrible over city. Good guy can't see girlfriend at daddy's funeral reminds me of the daredevil Electra scene in daredevil movie.

2. Some parts still appeared too polished and animated even when director said he intended more gritty realistic feel.. It couldn't make up its mind whether it was polished unrealistic Hollywood blockbuster or 500 days of summer superhero term angst flick.

3. I didn't like the sequence much related to Uncle Bens death.. Original was a little better.

4. The lizard in full cgi mode was artificial and sucked and his cheesy smile reminded me of the gorn from star trek or those lizard minster dudes from the 70s tv show land of the lost. What was Webb the director thinking?? I'm sure people on his team would have seen the similarities.. The mouth ESP was disconcerting and almost funny.

Here's my thoughts today, after a day of thinking about my film experience and my opinion especially after re reviewing the old clips and trailers showing stuff that wasn't in the final film:

A message to the producers and corporate big wigs who mercilessly hacked and cut the Amazing Spiderman so it had no coherence....you brag how great it was going to be and how profound the ending would be, then you cut out all the footage that ties the story together regarding Peter Parker's parents etc...take The Dark Knight Rises as inspiration you don't need to do a hack job, you CAN create a commercial success with great plot, drama etc...and be incredibly successful, but no, you took the easy way out, you losers!

SPIDER-MAN: 6 Most Exciting Possibilities For Tom Holland's Peter Parker And His Expanded MCU Role
Related:

SPIDER-MAN: 6 Most Exciting Possibilities For Tom Holland's Peter Parker And His Expanded MCU Role

SPIDER-MAN Is Returning To Macy's Thanksgiving Day Parade With Balloon Based On John Romita Sr.'s Artwork
Recommended For You:

SPIDER-MAN Is Returning To Macy's Thanksgiving Day Parade With Balloon Based On John Romita Sr.'s Artwork

DISCLAIMER: ComicBookMovie.com is protected under the DMCA (Digital Millenium Copyright Act) and... [MORE]

ComicBookMovie.com, and/or the user who contributed this post, may earn commissions or revenue through clicks or purchases made through any third-party links contained within the content above.

JamesXMan
JamesXMan - 7/9/2012, 3:04 PM
i'm sorry i didn't mean Sally Struthers..Sally Fields.
JamesXMan
JamesXMan - 7/9/2012, 3:05 PM
teen angst flick not term angst flick..darn iphone typo
CaptainAmerica31
CaptainAmerica31 - 7/10/2012, 11:23 AM
I loved the movie but I agree with the editing, it would have been amazing if it wasn't edited so poorly but I guess they're saving stuff for the sequel which I think is gonna be really good and possibly the best spider-man movie and CBM. IDK that's just me but this movie felt like a teaser for something greater to come.
JamesXMan
JamesXMan - 7/10/2012, 11:37 AM
Tweeted Marc Webb

@MarcW can you respond to our questions at our review at http://www.comicbookmovie.com/spider-man_movies/news/?a=63357

Let's see if he has the balls to respond and tell the truth about what went down or if he is too scared to tell the truth because he thinks he will be punished by the Sony execs....

Marc, if you read this, could you at least comment on the minus aspects of the film with the questions above as well as if you would be willing to make the Directors Cut DVD to show how you REALLY envisioned the story without all the hack edits??

JamesXMan
JamesXMan - 7/11/2012, 2:30 AM
KamenRider, There is no question the acting was much better and the film at times more gritter and realistic than Raimi's series...but you need to compare against the film clips and story parts that were cut out in the final edit that created incoherence in the story...if you recall the Sony execs didn't like the initial version and ended up hacking Marc's work....I seriously think whatever Marc intended and the screenplay written was different than what we ended up seeing...it was good, it was solid, not amazing. Dark Knight Returns will be amazing. See the difference_
koytoys
koytoys - 7/15/2012, 8:00 PM
agree with all the bad editing. yes, there were things done better in TASM, but there were also a lot of things done better in the first film.
View Recorder