Fancast: Batman

Fancast: Batman

Check out my cast for the Caped Crusader!

By MrBlueSky - Sep 12, 2014 07:09 AM EST
Filed Under: Fan Fic


First off, I was planning on posting this later in the month, but I decided to post it earlier because I wanted to cheer up my friend DDD, who's a great caster and an all around awesome guy. Anyway, I'm aware of the upcoming Batman reboot with Ben Affleck, and I am catiously excited for it. However, this cast is for my own take on Batman, a superhero that I have known and loved ever since I was 5 years old.

 

Anyway, my pick for director for this series would be David Fincher, director of Se7enFight Club, and the American adaptation of The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo. He's one of my favorite directors, and I think his dark and gritty style would fit for an adaptation of Batman. And for this take, I want it to be grounded in reality, but not completely realistic like the Nolan films. I want it to take place in a world where it's still capable for things like aliens and magic to exist. 







Anyway, enjoy the cast!



Heroes:



Alex O'Loughlin (MoonlightingWhite Out) as Bruce Wayne/Batman: The son of millionaire philanphropists Thomas and Martha Wayne, who witnessed his parent's murder in front of him. Since then, Bruce as devoted his life to fighting crime as the vigilante Batman. Bruce is a highly skilled detective, martial artist, escapologist, and strategist. He uses a variety of bat-themed weaponry and gadgets, including a custom car called the Batmobile. 







Reason for Casting: O'Loughlin has been a popular choice for Batman for some time now, and I was hoping he'd been pick for the role before Ben Affleck. Anyway, he's a great actor (as seen on Hawaii Five-0), and has the right physique and rugged good looks for Batman. Plus, he's already played a detective that operates at night on Moonlighting.

 

Anthony Steward Head (Buffy the Vampire SlayerMerlin) as Alfred Pennyworth: The Wayne family butler, who raised Bruce and served as his surrogate father figure ever since the death of his parents. Alfred helps Bruce in his fight against crime, usually serving as his medic. 







Reason for Casting: I originally had John Hurt in this role, but I decided that he was too old. Anyway, Head is a good actor, and he's already played a similar role on Bu ffy. I think he'd be great as Alfred.

 

Terrence Howard (Hustle and FlowDead Man Down) as Lucius Fox: The CEO of Wayne Enterprises, who helps Bruce by creating gadgets and vehicles that Bruce has designed. 







Reason for Casting: I know this may seem like an odd casting choice. Howard has a lot of charm and charisma, and it was seeing him in Dead Man Down, where he pulled off the right look for Fox, that convinced me to cast him. 



Brad Pitt (Killing Them SoftlyFury) as Commissoner Jim Gordon: The commissoner of the Gothim City Police, who oftern works with Batman. He is skeptical of Batman's vigilante methods, but recognizes the necessity of him, and has a mutual respect for the Caped Crusader. 







Reason for Casting: I've decided not to go with Bryan Cranston as Gordon, since it's overused. Anyway, Pitt is a great actor, who has worked with David Fincher before. It was mainly his role in Se7en that convinced me to cast him as Jim Gordon. I have a feeling he'd do a great job in the role. 



Kevin Chapman (Rescue MePerson of Interest) as Detective Harvey Bullock:  A seemingly corrupt detective on the force, who is extremely loyal to Gordon. Having a fondness for donuts and a hidden sentimental streak, he's also very distrusting of Batman. 







Reason for Casting: I originally had James Gandolfini in the role, but he unfortunately passed away. Anyway, Chapman is a pretty good actor, and it helps that he's played a corrupt detective before on Person of Interest. I think he would do really well as Bullock, giving a performance similar to Robert Costanzo.



Alice Braga (PredatorsElysium) as Detective Reynee Montoya: A detetctive from the Major Crimes Unit, who is also another good cop on the force. 







Reason for Casting: Again, I didn't want to go with someone obvious like Michelle Rodriguez (who I think is overrated). Braga has played a tough chick before in Predators, and I think she'd be good as Montoya. 



Common (Street Kings, Hell on Wheels) as Detective Crispus Allen: Montoya's partner from the Major Crime Unit. Allen sees Batman as a necessary evil, not wanting to deal with him personally, but tolerating his existance. 






Reason for Casting: I know that a lot of rappers aren't very good at acting, but I see Common as one of those exceptions. He's great on Hell on Wheels, and I think he'd do great as Allen. 

Villains:

Michael Sheen (Midnight in ParisMasters of Sex) as The Joker: A psychopathic criminal mastermind, and Batman's archnemesis. The Joker posses a warped, twisted sense of humor, and his plans only make sense to himself. The Joker uses a variety of gag-themed weapons, but is not above using things like knives. 



Reason for Casting: Sheen's a fantastic actor, and he's good at playing deranged as seen in Unthinkable. In fact, his roles in Unthinkable and Tron: Legacy that convinced me that he'd be a great Joker. 

Andrew Scott (Sherlock, Lennon Naked) as Edward Nygma/The Riddler: A criminal obssessed with puzzles, and delights in sending complex clues to forewarn both Batman and the police. The Riddler is a genius with a wide variety of knowledge and different styles of thinking, but ususally excels in different styles of thinking. 



Reason for Casting: I have to admit that this choice mainly comes from Scott's performance on Sherlock. He was a great cerebral villain there, and he'd be good as the Riddler. 

Zachary Quinto (HeroesAmerican Horror Story) as Dr. Johnathan Crane/The Scarecrow: A psychologist who uses a variety of drugs and psychological tactics to intimidate fear in his victims. The Scarecrow is an expert hand-to-hand combatant, and mainly uses a fear toxin to make a victim to hallucinate their greatest fear. 



Reason for Casting: Quinto has a very creepy, unsettling vibe to him, as seen  in Heroes and American Horror Story. He'd make a very unnerving and scary Scarecrow. 

Dominic Cooper (Mamma Mia!An Education) as Harvey Dent/Two-Face: The former district attorney of Gotham, who had half of his face horribly scarred, making him become the criminal Two-Face. Dent has an obession with the number two, and makes many of his decisions with a coin flip. He also uses dual firearms (such as .22 semiautomatics or a double-barreled shotgun). 



Reason for Casting: I know that this may seem like an out-of-the-left field chocie, but I think Cooper would do good as Dent, since he has this charisma to him that would work with the role. 

Eliza Dushku (Wrong Turn, Dollhouse) as Selina Kyle/Catwoman: A cat burgular who has a complex love-hate relationship with Batman. Catwoman is a skilled acrobat and matial artist. She also uses a whip, and her costume has climbing talons and retractable claws. 



Reason for Casting: Dushku is a great actress, has played seductresses before, and is pretty familiar with action. She'd be great as Catwoman. 

Jon Bernthal (The Walking DeadMob City) as Roman Sionis/Black Mask: A powerful and violent crime boss who is known for wearing a black, skull-shaped mask. Roman is a skilled hand-to-hand combatant with enhanced strenghth and endurance, and is also known for carrying around handguns. 



Reason for Casting: What convinced me to cast Bernthal was his role on The Walking Dead (mainly him in the 2nd season), that convinced me to cast him as Mask. 

Norman Reedus (The Boondock Saints, Pandorum) as Floyd Lawton/Deadshot: An assassin-for-hire that is known for his excellent marksmanship. Besdies his marksmanship, he has a cybernetic eyes that grants him increased accuracy, and also uses a variety of firearms, incluidng a wrist-mounted machine gun. 



Reason for Casting: This role mainly came from Reedus's role on The Walking Dead. He was badass there, and he would be even more badass as Deadshot. 

Matthew Goode (A Single ManThe Good Wife) as Dr. Thomas Elliot/Hush: A childhood friend of Bruce Wayne, who is now obssessed with destroying Batman. Hush is a master surgeon, tactician, strategist, martial artist, athelete, and marksman. His main weapon is a pair of handguns.



Reason for Casting: Goode's a great actor, and it was mainlt his creepy, unsettling perfomance as Uncle Charlie  in Stoker that convinced me to cast him. He'd be great as a dark reflection of Batman. 

Dominic Purcell (Prison BreakJohn Doe) as Waylon Jones/Killer Croc: A criminal with a rare skin condition that gives him a crocodile like appearance. Jones posses superhuman attributes, along with harden skin, razor sharp claws and teeth, and an immunity to toxins. 



Reason for Casting: Purcell is great at playing thuggish characters. He'd fit a role like this, rather than a role like Venom.

Edgar Ramirez (The Bourne UltimatumThe Counsoler) as Bane: A South-American criminal genius, whose tactical prowness is on par with Batman's. Besides being a tactical genius and strategist, Pain also posses superhuman strength, which he enhances with a drug called Venom. 



Reason for Casting: Ramirez is a great actor, and what convinced me to cast him was his performance as Carlos the Jackal in Carlos.

Jason Clarke (LawlessWhite House Down) as Matt Hagen/Clayface: A criminal that can transform himself into living clay. Hagen can shapeshift himself, and can recompose his body from mud if it is ever destroyed. 



Reason for Casting: Clarke's a really talented and underrated actor who I can see own the role of Clayface, especially if they went with the Batman: The Animated Series route with the character.

Christina Ricci (Monster, Penelope) as Dr. Harleen Quinzel/Harley Quinn: A A physchiatrist at Arkham who fell madly in love with the Joker and joined him as his accomplice. Quinn is a talented gyminist with enhanced strength and agility, and primarily uses a mallet as her weapon of choice. 



Reason for Casting: Ricci's a talented actress, who has done dark work before and I think she can nail the creepy and psychotic parts of the character. 

Kevin Spacey (House of CardsThe Men who Stare at Goats) as Hugo Strange: A psychologist who was hired to deduce the identity of Batman, until he became obssessed with the Dark Knight himself. Strange has a genius level intellect, and posses a mastery of the field of psychology.



Reason for Casting: Spacey has to be one of my favorite actors, and is criminally underrated. If you've seen him in Se7en or The Usual Suspects, then he'd own a role like Strange. 

Noomi Rapace (PrometheusDead man Down) as Talia Al Ghul: The on/off love interest of Batman, who is the daughter of Ras Al Ghul and the leader of the  League of Assassins. Talia is a master of hand-to-hand combat and use of weaponry. 



Reason for Casting: Rapace is a great actress, and one of my favorites. She knows her way around action and would be great as Talia.

Christopher Lambert (HighlanderSouthland Tales) as Ras Al Ghul: A terrorist who wants to purge the earth of modern humanity, and restore it to its natural state again. Ras posses logetivity from the  Lazarus Pits, along with a genius level intellect, superior strength and stamina, and knowledge in martial arts, fencing, and alchemy. 



Reason for Casting: Do I really have to explain this? It's Connor freakin' MacLeod fighting Batman! How awesome would that be?

Anyway, please leave your thoughts and comments below. I hope that you have enjoyed this cast. 
DC & Marvel Team Up In Awesome Fan-Created Infinite Crisis Video
Related:

DC & Marvel Team Up In Awesome Fan-Created "Infinite Crisis" Video

Bill Cosby Says He Wants To Be In A Superhero Film
Recommended For You:

Bill Cosby Says He Wants To Be In A Superhero Film

DISCLAIMER: ComicBookMovie.com is protected under the DMCA (Digital Millenium Copyright Act) and... [MORE]

ComicBookMovie.com, and/or the user who contributed this post, may earn commissions or revenue through clicks or purchases made through any third-party links contained within the content above.

1 2
CherryBomb
CherryBomb - 9/12/2014, 7:52 AM
I adore these casting choices! Really great job.
My only complaint is Eliza Dushku as Selina, I just don't see it at all.
She's a great actress but personally she's better on the small screen, and I don't think she can really embody Catwoman, who's more subtle. She shines when she's playing the louder, out-there characters like Faith.
MightyZeus
MightyZeus - 9/12/2014, 7:52 AM
This cast is awesome. I love everything about it.

Great work, man.
CherryBomb
CherryBomb - 9/12/2014, 7:56 AM
Maybe Olivia Wilde?

CherryBomb
CherryBomb - 9/12/2014, 7:57 AM
Michael Sheen would be amazing as the Joker!
BobGarlen
BobGarlen - 9/12/2014, 8:08 AM
I see a few of my own choices here. Great work.
CharlesLord
CharlesLord - 9/12/2014, 8:12 AM
Before they cast Affleck, my pick for Batman was always Dillon Casey and my pick for Riddler was always myself lol.
scruffylookingnerfherder
scruffylookingnerfherder - 9/12/2014, 8:19 AM
CAST ALL THE VILLAINS! Good list, though.
DDD
DDD - 9/12/2014, 8:27 AM
@MRBLUESKY...

Wow, another fantastic fancast!

(Thanks for the cheer-up, btw!)

Unbelievable...CONNOR FREAKIN' MCLEOD as RAS...WOW, JUST WOW!
Never saw that coming...BEAUTIFUL!

You've populated this Casting with WAY out-of-the-box people!
Just SIMPLY WONDERFUL!

Everyone clicks with me.

As you probably know I've been touting ELIZA as CATWOMAN for forever. She would own the role!

I truly love some of these left-field choices!

My fave...DOMINIC COOPER as HARVEY DENT, He would play a realistic madman with scary credibility. This man has talent squirting out his pores!

Finally, a Latino actor for a Latino character, BANE.
This actor is amazing and very unsung.

I really, really didn't see BRAD PITT coming as GORDON.
After INGLORIOUS BASTERDS I now believe. Great original choice!

A+ Casting!

FAN-FREAKIN'-FANTASTIC!
MikeZ
MikeZ - 9/12/2014, 8:40 AM
O... M... G! It's about [frick]in' time we see this hit the interwebz! ZOMG!

And CherryBomb, are you trying to kill me with those Olivia Wilde .gifs? Especially the top one?!

- O' Loughlin is one of my choices for Green Lantern. But if I ever watch Moonlight, I'll see if he would be eligible for Bats!
- Well, seems like you got my choice for Alfred Pennysworth!
- I don't know if you heard, but what do you think of Mark Harmon as Jim Gordon? He'd be perfect for a more veteran Jim Gordon. Kind of a nod seeing as he's been fancast to death as George Stacy in every Spider-Man fancast.
- For the record, Michelle Rodriguez isn't too overrated if you ask me. But yeah, thumbs up for an original Montoya. My choices would be Janina Gavankar or Erica Cerra (she's sexy and talented enough to bypass the emphysema voice).
- Common always impresses if you ask me.
- I'd def go with Michael Sheen as Joker based on Tron Legacy as well!
- I think Eliza Dushku said "sayanora" to acting to voice She-Hulk. Of course, there is that Scribbler film with Katie Cassidy that people are creaming their shorts over. Okay, screw it, she would do good as Catwoman on the silver screen!
- Killer Croc, at least from what I've been spoon-fed, was of African-American decent. Still, I'm a fan of Dominic Purcell, and would love to see what he can offer.
- Smart move going younger, and someone other than Javier Bardem, for Bane.
- Christina Ricci played Lizzie Borden, so I can see how she'd be a great choice for Harley Quinn.
- Seems like you've been inspired by Robert Garlen's Arkham fancast, huh? Great picks for the al Ghul family! Although I'd like someone with a slightly more curvaceous body for Talia.

Other than that, great cast! Can't wait to see what you got in store for next! Let's keep Comicbookmovie from going the YouTube route and becoming a joke.
DDD
DDD - 9/12/2014, 8:43 AM
@CHERRYBOMB,

Olivia Wilde is flat-chested.
CATWOMAN has big bazoombas!

ELIZA has done tons of subtle!
She has been in big screen films, she's not JUST a TV actress.
She's model beautiful which is what CATWOMAN is.

Anne Hathaway is a "BUTTER-FACE". she didn't fit SELINA at all.
Maybe CATWOMAN when her face was covered but not SELINA.

CATWOMAN is not just a body, she's a drop-dead gorgeous supermodel face.

What is all this snobbery against TV actresses?

Oh, well!

MrDonut
MrDonut - 9/12/2014, 8:46 AM
YES. YES. YES. [frick]ING YES!
Very solid cast, a lot of choices I like here (glad you've taken a shine to Clarke as Clayface- one of my old picks), some we even share lol... But hell, overall very nice cast- the only one that I'm not too keen on is; Pitt as Gordon- he'd undoubtedly nail it, and is actually within the right age range, but I've wanted him for Deathstroke for a while now, and would personally prefer someone a little more 'underdog'-like for the role...

Regardless, bout time you dropped this, solid work, thumbs up defo!
DDD
DDD - 9/12/2014, 8:50 AM
@ROADDOG,

definitely check out MOONLIGHT!
O'LOUGHLIN is basically playing a VAMPIRE BATMAN, there.

VAMPIRE BAT-MAN to "THE" BATMAN...not much of a stretch!
lol

But seriously O'LOUGHLIN truly fits.
CherryBomb
CherryBomb - 9/12/2014, 9:26 AM
@DDD

It's not all about the breasts -_-
Olivia Wilde is primarily a TV actress, there's no snobbery involved. I just see Eliza in a more guns-blazing less subdued role, like Huntress, that's what suits her more IMO.
Pasto
Pasto - 9/12/2014, 9:38 AM
Literally spit everywhere when I saw the comment about Olivia being flat-chested.
Pasto
Pasto - 9/12/2014, 9:39 AM
Welcome to nerd-culture, where tits are the deciding factor if an actress can play a certain role.
MikeZ
MikeZ - 9/12/2014, 10:01 AM
@ Yutz

Well, I'm not sure if Olivia's boobs grown since pregnancy. But I saw some GQ/Esquire shoot where she was playing with her boobs (ironically), and they're not flat. Olivia would be great as Catwoman, but maybe during the Year One run. But I think she fits more bright-shaded characters.

@ DDD

Well, when I have room in my Netflix Queue, I'll be hitting that series up!

@ MrBlueSky

I have one more request. Would you mind casting some of the Batgirls, as well as the Robins? I seen you cast - and perfectly, may I add - Tim Drake on deviantART, so why not bring that in, and cast Nightwing, Damien Wayne, Batgirl (Barbara Gordon), Black Bat, and Spoiler as well. Do that, and I'll help promote this cast somehow.
Pasto
Pasto - 9/12/2014, 10:15 AM
@RoadDogXXIV
Agreedo.
Pasto
Pasto - 9/12/2014, 10:16 AM
@RoadDogXXIV
I could see Wilde as Hawk-Girl in all honesty. Or maybe even Carol Ferris.
Spooks
Spooks - 9/12/2014, 10:17 AM
I love this cast, mate. My only nitpick is your Bruce choice, but that may just be because I don't know who the hell he is haha. My absolute favorite pick of yours is Anthony Stewart Head as Alfred. That is brilliant! Might have to steal it for my own fancast some day ;)

Also, FYI your picture you have posted for Jon Bernthal is actually Edward Burns, a completely different actor :P
Spooks
Spooks - 9/12/2014, 10:20 AM
@Yutz "Welcome to nerd-culture, where tits are the deciding factor if an actress can play a certain role."

Pasto
Pasto - 9/12/2014, 10:30 AM
@Spooks

DDD
DDD - 9/12/2014, 11:16 AM
@YUTZ,
check out some of the bikini photos of WILDE on GOOGLE, she's definitely small-chested.
She would have to wear some really big falsies to do the role correctly.
But WILDE would look ridiculous!

Yup, most of the super-heroines are drawn large-chested and that's a somewhat silly exaggeration.
But CATWOMAN is truly a well-endowed character.
It's part of her persona not just an exaggeration.

She's a well-endowed supermodel sort, with an extra-beautiful face.
It's a very integral part of what SELINA KYLE is.
To ignore that in her character in a casting destroys her character.
It would be like making JUGGERNAUT a midget!
DDD
DDD - 9/12/2014, 11:20 AM
Even NOLAN knew that he needed a well-endowed actress to play CATWOMAN.

ANNE HATHAWAY is definitely well-endowed.
lol

But her face.......oh man!
lol
DDD
DDD - 9/12/2014, 11:26 AM
@LUTZ,
Tits aren't a deciding factor with most super-heroines, that's true!

Yeah, WILDE would be good as either HAWKGIRL or CAROL FERRIS....
maybe even TALIA AL GHUL.
She could pull-off TALIA'S dangerous conflicted persona.
DDD
DDD - 9/12/2014, 11:32 AM
@CHERRY BOMB,
You're right, ELIZA would make an excellent HUNTRESS!
MrBlueSky
MrBlueSky - 9/12/2014, 12:55 PM
@ CherryBomb Thank you! I'm glad you like Sheen as the Joker. I disagree with you about Dushku, since she did voice in Batman: Year One. ANd I have to agree with DDDL Olivia doesn't have the right cleavage size for Selina.

@ MightyZeus Thanks

@ DoctorAlgenorKrieger Thanks!

@ Charleslord 'kay. WHat do you think of my cast?

@ scruffylookingnerfherder That would take far too long, man.

@ DDD Thanks! Glad you like Lambert, Cooper, Ramirez, Pitt, and Eliza. And thank you for pointing out how to properly cast Catwoman.

@ RoadDogXXIV Thanks man!

- I can see Harmon as Gordon, but what do you think about Pitt as Gordon?

- I have a feeling that Dushku is completely wasted on that stupid show.

- Thanks, I'll try to have a Secret Six or Transformers cast up next.

- And actually, I don't really feel l like casting the Robins or Batgirls.

@ MrDonut Thanks, man! I can definitely see Brad Pitt as Deathstroke!

@ Yutz Lol.

@ Spooks Thanks man! Glad you like my Alfred pick. And I'll fix that picture of Black Mask immediately.

MikeZ
MikeZ - 9/12/2014, 2:32 PM
@ MrBlueSky

- Well, I saw Pitt on Senor Robert Garlen's Batman Year One cast. I prefer seeing him play kooky and eccentric characters, but hey, go with what you want. And Pitt did play it serious in World War Z.
- No shit.
- Good luck with 'em.
- Boo!
FirstAvenger
FirstAvenger - 9/12/2014, 2:35 PM
This a pretty awesome cast! :)
CherryBomb
CherryBomb - 9/12/2014, 3:30 PM
Tut you men and your "every superheroine must have DD breasts" - Selina's main equalities are her intellect, seductive skills and charm, not her breasts, she doesn't need them, she has more than enough personality to compensate.
fatcobra
fatcobra - 9/12/2014, 3:40 PM
Not too shabby. We actually have the same picks for Bane and Clayface. Here's my Fancasts for the Batverse:

http://www.comicbookmovie.com/fan_fic/news/?a=87446
http://www.comicbookmovie.com/fan_fic/news/?a=87780

Check them out if you've got a minute.
Good Job!
kong
kong - 9/12/2014, 4:32 PM
I really like it! I mean I've seen 60% of them before, but at least you copied good fancasters (even see some of my pics in there).
SidDaAstroSloth
SidDaAstroSloth - 9/12/2014, 6:57 PM
Olivia Wilde is Catwoman to me. Just eyes have sold me....


I do love your choices for Black Mask amd Deadshot
SwanRonson
SwanRonson - 9/12/2014, 8:40 PM
Amazing cast!
superbatspiderman
superbatspiderman - 9/12/2014, 9:38 PM
Your picture of Jon Beranthal is Edward Burns not JOn Beranthal.
MrBlueSky
MrBlueSky - 9/13/2014, 12:52 PM
@RoadDogXXIV Would Tyler Durden count as kooky and eccentric?

And this cast is for a Batman that's just starting his career.

@TheFirstAvenger97 Thank you!

@CherryBomb I'm not saying that! DDD is!

@fat cobra I'll definitely check them out, man!

@RedNTheHood Thanks man! Which of my picks do we share?

@SidTheManicorn I have Wilde for another role in mind, but glad you like my Deadshot and Black Mask picks.

@SwanRonson Thank you!

@superbatspiderman Someone already pointed that out. What do you think of my cast?

SwanRonson
SwanRonson - 9/13/2014, 2:16 PM
No problem man.

@DDD usually I agree with you but it's a bit sexist to cast a part based off of breasts. Specifically a role that hasn't or ever will be defined by that.
TheSoulEater
TheSoulEater - 9/13/2014, 2:17 PM
BRILLIANT ALFRED choice
SwanRonson
SwanRonson - 9/13/2014, 2:17 PM
Selina Kyle is hot. Olivia Wilde is hot. Big breasts do NOT equal hot. Michelle P doesn't have huge boobs, did that matter for me as a kid or even now? Hell NO!
kong
kong - 9/13/2014, 3:02 PM
Kevin Spacey as Hugo Strange and Michael Sheen as Joker. Though my last Batman fan cast featuring the Joker had a different actor than Sheen.
FanWriter97
FanWriter97 - 9/13/2014, 4:14 PM
Nice. I can see them. Especially Alfred's since I'm a huge fan of Buffy.
1 2
View Recorder