EDITORIAL: Smallville, An Elseworlds Tale

EDITORIAL: Smallville, An Elseworlds Tale

I originally started this as a comment, but it evolved into a full thought process about the series.

Editorial Opinion
By AEStark - Jan 11, 2011 07:01 PM EST
Filed Under: Smallville

Ugh. Ok, as someone fairly new to the site, I feel obligated to at least one smallville sucks comment. While I don't think the concept sucks (that being life before the suit), beyond season 4 they ought to have slapped a big elseworlds sticker on it. That's when they started introducing characters into continuity that he shouldn't have met yet. After that, it became a matter of holding up a falling house, and everything we knew about the mythos was tossed.

Now, in an effort to keep viewership, they keep dangling the suit carrot. The problem with that is now your viewers are waiting weekly for a payoff that may not even come, not to mention the fact that he'll probably have the suit before he can fly, because they are still slaving to the "no flights, no tights" policy they came up with a decade ago. They tried to stretch a four year plan for ten years, and it shows.

Oh, and Chloe is a waist of airtime. All she does is give us the obligatory one-liner that all shows after 7pm have to have nowadays, and say the product placement line of the week. Every episode designed to make her feel important to the cast fall flat and detract from the main story. Half of the episodes about her don't have the main villain in it.

Again, I enjoy the show. Enjoyed the show. I just feel as though it's a surrealist view of the mythos. And every week, I sit in front of my tv, hoping they'd fix it. They don't. And each week I'm dissatisfied, but (like so many of us here) I've invested so much time in the series, I'm committed because I'm owed a payoff. At some point the series has to end. At some point they have to deliver.

SMALLVILLE Star James Marsters Is Open To Reprising Brainiac Role In Possible Animated Revival
Related:

SMALLVILLE Star James Marsters Is Open To Reprising Brainiac Role In Possible Animated Revival

SMALLVILLE Star Tom Welling Reflects On Batman Not Appearing And How He'd Have Liked A Cameo To Play Out
Recommended For You:

SMALLVILLE Star Tom Welling Reflects On Batman Not Appearing And How He'd Have Liked A Cameo To Play Out

DISCLAIMER: ComicBookMovie.com is protected under the DMCA (Digital Millenium Copyright Act) and... [MORE]

ComicBookMovie.com, and/or the user who contributed this post, may earn commissions or revenue through clicks or purchases made through any third-party links contained within the content above.

AEStark
AEStark - 1/11/2011, 8:39 PM
I didn't say the others were perfect. However, nothing I said was untrue.
AEStark
AEStark - 1/11/2011, 8:55 PM
@Superguy1591 No worries. I get that smallville is a polarizing subject around here. I just think people would enjoy it more if they took it at face value.
YourMomNaked
YourMomNaked - 1/12/2011, 6:22 AM
@AEStark...LMFAO...have you lived under a rock for the past decade of Smallville? Have you only just discovered CBM? You write this article as if this is some grand epiphany. It's called RETCON. Everybody does it.
LEEE777
LEEE777 - 1/12/2011, 11:06 AM
Yeah, its been pretty much an ELSEWORLDS since first ep lol...

But it turned to sh1T by season 8!

Its hard to enjoy it these days! : (

Gr8 review an thumbs up buddy!
scrivo29
scrivo29 - 1/12/2011, 12:48 PM
ok i love smallville why do u say that season 8 onwards was shit the only season that was shit was season 8 s9 brought it back to great but good review!
Smallvilleisgood
Smallvilleisgood - 1/12/2011, 4:26 PM
I can't be bothered with people who have no [frick]ing clue what they are on about.
ThunderKat
ThunderKat - 1/13/2011, 12:36 AM
It didn't evolve. It just became a large comment. If you don't like it, turn it off. Some cartoons have followed book storylines closely, though not exactly. No TV shows nor movies have. Again, large comment.
Knightstalker
Knightstalker - 1/13/2011, 7:25 PM
Why does every one here (except you LEEE777) have to harp on AEStark simply for saying what many (obviously not all) of us have been feeling for the last few years. Yes, they are dragging out this whole growing up and growing into Superman thing. We've all been waiting for it and are all realizing that we are going to be disappointed. We have every right to be unhappy about it. If you like or love the show blindly, then good for you. More power to you. Just don't expect the rest of to fall in line with the rest of the sheeple. Some of us have higher expectations.
Jameskid00
Jameskid00 - 1/17/2011, 11:33 PM
alright i kept beleif of no flights no tights which i really dont give a bull if he wears the suit or as long he wears it but i do want see him fly that i want see. i hate that superman returns emblem so i stayed watching i have realized that this is the SMALLVILLE UNIVERSE i wish it could be played more to the orignal story but im alright with it and kept watcing becuase the story is brilliant evan with its faults
Jameskid00
Jameskid00 - 1/17/2011, 11:38 PM
alright i kept beleif of no flights no tights which i really dont give a bull if he wears the suit or as long he wears it but i do want see him fly that i want see. i hate that superman returns emblem
View Recorder