EDITORIAL: Why I May Have Been Wrong About X-Men: First Class Being The Worst CBM Ever!

EDITORIAL: Why I May Have Been Wrong About X-Men: First Class Being The Worst CBM Ever!

Last August, I wrote an editorial declaring that X-Men: First Class would undoubtedly be the worst comic book movie ever. Now, I'm beginning to think the opposite. Find out why, along with my take on the trailerand more, here...

Editorial Opinion
By JoshWilding - Feb 24, 2011 01:02 PM EST
Filed Under: X-Men: First Class



I hate to say it. I really do. I'm actually looking forward to seeing X-Men: First Class! Good God, I think I just threw up in my mouth a little... As I'm sure you all must surely know, I've been one of the biggest haters towards the movie. When it was announced that Matthew Vaughn would be directing, and that it would be set in the 1960s, I was fine. "Could Fox finally be about to make a good comic book movie?" I wondered. It was Bryan Singer's revelation that it would not follow the original five and some seemingly dubious casting and character decisions that had me all but ready to burn Fox's headquarters down though. Apart from one or two decent enough decisions (Michael Fassbender as Magneto!) I could find nothing to like about X-Men: First Class. it was truly shaping up in my eyes to be one awful [frick]ing movie. And it was at that time, I decided to write a rather controversial editorial.

What was that editorial?

Why X-Men: First Class Will Probably Be The Worst CBM Ever!

Extreme, but that really was how I felt. Hell, I still do to a large extent. So what changed my mind!? Well, those unexciting set photos sure as hell did nothing to alter my opinion. The only thing the really assured me of was that Vaughn had successfully made a convincing looking period piece. To be fair, I thought the costumes were good (or at least a million times better than the leather monstrosities of the first three films) and Magneto's helmet was PERFECT. I was feeling a little more positively towards the film perhaps, but still had little to no interest in seeing Fox butcher any more of my favourite comic book characters. Then, the trailer was released. And all of a sudden, I was suddenly looking forward to X-Men: First Class as much as Thor, Green Lantern and Captain America: The First Avenger! Phew, I feel like I need to take a shower after confessing to such a thing! After all, we're talking about the same studio that made movies like Fantastic Four, Elektra and...well...every other bad comic book movie you can think of! I do realise that it's far too early to suddenly declare this latest effort as being better, based only on a teaser trailer and handful of impressive interviews with the cast. Only seeing it on June 2 (gotta love living in the UK) will ultimately decide whether it's any good or not. I do however think it's important to note that I no longer think it will be as bad as any of us either predicted or expected.

That trailer had everything in it that I always wanted to see in an X-Men movie. I hated Singer's two and Ratner's equally as much. (I won't go into why as I've done that plenty of times before elsewhere) Vaughn however has seemingly managed to find the perfect balance of politics and action, just as the comic books always have. The Blackbird scenes should be truly epic, while the rest of the action looked like it had been translated directly from the comic books themselves. (at least I could see nothing as lame as the Wolverine vs. Wolverine fight from the first one) And as much as I like Ian McKellen, how great is it to have a Magneto who actually looks menacing rather than one who looks like he should be in a retirement home? McAvoy also impressed me as Xavier, while they've nailed the looks of Beast, Emma Frost and Mystique equally well.

The problem that remains, is the drastic changes from the source material. I'm pretty sure that whatever the movie ends up being like, I'll find it hard to get over them. The fact is, it's out of our hands. However much we all complain, studios like Fox will continue making these movies. Why? They make a crap load of cash. We can talk about boycotting these films as much as we like, and perhaps the critics will dislike this as much as they have the past few. Even so, over two million people signed up to the Facebook page in anticipation of the trailer reveal. The response from non comic book fans? Pretty damn positive. It even changed my mind and many other fanboys, as you can see from this editorial, which is pretty astonishing considering that I once flat out refused to go and watch the movie. What I'm saying is that it might just be worth giving X-Men: First Class a chance. There's no denying that it will not be a good adaptation of the source material. But maybe, just maybe, they'll do enough right with the characters and story to make a decent film.

Recent reports have seemingly hinted at them introducing characters like Cyclops and Jean Grey in the sequels. While this is far from how the comic books did it, we could really be in for something great here. It's easy to hate Fox. Everything they do is seemingly another reason for us to do just that. But perhaps it's time to have faith in them doing the right thing. They've hired Matthew Vaughn for this, and the brilliant Darren Aronofsky for The Wolverine. Take a look at what we know about Captain America and Thor. Both of those are seemingly completely original stories not based on any specific stories. Steve will be a part of the USO. Bucky will have no mask. A powerless Thor lands on Earth and calls himself Donald Blake. Pretty far from the comics, but Marvel Studios earned our trust with Iron Man and The Incredible Hulk. Maybe X-Men: First Class is doing the same. If for one am looking forward to it. And I NEVER thought I'd say THAT.




Image and video hosting by TinyPic



X-MEN: FIRST CLASS Was Partially Written In Claudia Schiffer's Hospital Room Due To Rushed Production
Related:

X-MEN: FIRST CLASS Was Partially Written In Claudia Schiffer's Hospital Room Due To Rushed Production

Matthew Vaughn Reveals Scrapped Plans For X-MEN: FIRST CLASS Trilogy And Who He Was Going To Cast As Wolverine
Recommended For You:

Matthew Vaughn Reveals Scrapped Plans For X-MEN: FIRST CLASS Trilogy And Who He Was Going To Cast As Wolverine

DISCLAIMER: ComicBookMovie.com is protected under the DMCA (Digital Millenium Copyright Act) and... [MORE]

ComicBookMovie.com, and/or the user who contributed this post, may earn commissions or revenue through clicks or purchases made through any third-party links contained within the content above.

1 2 3 4
AlexdoxA
AlexdoxA - 2/24/2011, 2:08 PM
Yeah I'll probably go to see it on the first day...
nuck82
nuck82 - 2/24/2011, 2:10 PM
who said you were wrong? lol


SOAL!
SuperSpiderMan5778
SuperSpiderMan5778 - 2/24/2011, 2:13 PM
didn't wanna read all that but you will be one of the many who hated and then later will be shut the fawked up once this movie makes u butter your popcorn with your own geekgasm. haha jk man but yeah this movie is gonna rock.
fightingfoo93
fightingfoo93 - 2/24/2011, 2:15 PM
It's kind of a dick thing to say a movie is crap before it's out. Now I can't say I'm to excited to see this movie but I'm not going to say it's the worst CBM ever.
Frecks
Frecks - 2/24/2011, 2:16 PM
Josh :( How could you!
imnotwearinghockeypants
imnotwearinghockeypants - 2/24/2011, 2:16 PM
You're wrong because there's no way it'll be worse than the Trifecta of Hellish CBM's that is Ghostrider, Daredevil and Catwoman. And don't try to defend Daredevil, I'd rather have watched a pile of dogshit dry on a sidewalk for two hours. Exhibit A: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tJlwo9iZO-w
HavocT
HavocT - 2/24/2011, 2:16 PM
How do I "hit" a jump?
CraptainAmerica
CraptainAmerica - 2/24/2011, 2:17 PM
Tipping my hat to you for admitting it. Most would just change their minds and say "I thought it would be good all along".

Always bed to see if the proof us in the pudding IMO
SwedishSkinJer
SwedishSkinJer - 2/24/2011, 2:21 PM
Your comment about Ian McKellen bugs me somewhat, even though it wasn't meant to be even negative. Yes, even though he looked old (although not every elderly person is automatically frail or in a nursing home...), I didn't find anything particularly wrong with this, as it's IAN MCKELLEN. He brought gravitas and class to Magneto and the intelligence that his voice implies when it reaches its most dramatic heights (his speech in X-Men 3 about mutants representing the true cure) is peerless. I hope Fassbender is able to live up to his performance because Sir Ian set one hell of a standard.

IMO, Ian's portrayal was more layered than generic, growling menace. His VOICE implies intelligence and menace; it's not all about physicality.
MovieMann
MovieMann - 2/24/2011, 2:21 PM
I don't understand how people can label something as the "WORST MOVIE EVER" before they have even seen it.
BezierCurve
BezierCurve - 2/24/2011, 2:22 PM
You could summarize by saying "I haven't seen it yet, so can't judge it merits at all".
CaptainOtter
CaptainOtter - 2/24/2011, 2:24 PM
Eh, I still dont have big expectations. The trailer was kinda "meh". All it had was a speech from JFK and shots of the entire cast. I think Michael Fassbender could do some great things as Magneto, but McAvoy didn't impress me. The trailer wasnt bad, it just had little in it.

What bothers me even more is the rushed production process. They're barely getting it together in time, and whenever people walk on and off of movies it's never a good sign. While this doesn't prove the movie will be bad, it's not a good sign.

But the big thing is that I didn't need this movie. We've had three X-Men movies. I don't need a prequel.
luckylu
luckylu - 2/24/2011, 2:24 PM
maybe electra has this one beat but it will still be one of the worst attempts.
SwedishSkinJer
SwedishSkinJer - 2/24/2011, 2:25 PM
Well, as wary as I still am about this movie, MovieMann, I don't think it will be nearly as bad as, say, Catwoman or Fantastic Four. I trust Vaughn more than no-names that had little experience with action (Catwoman's director and Tim Story).
Xandera
Xandera - 2/24/2011, 2:27 PM
Kudos Josh for having the balls to admit that... but I am still on the fence...

Guys, check out the Eleventh Sub-chapter of WHITE FIRE... Unforeseen Battle!

White Fire
LP4
LP4 - 2/24/2011, 2:27 PM
I've been excited about this film from the start even back since the first leaked photos that were "unexciting" for other people perhaps but not to me. This and Spider-Man are the only 2 CBMs I've been excited for.

Brashlight
Brashlight - 2/24/2011, 2:28 PM
Great stuff JW, it takes some serious cajones to write that up. I also appreciate your approach to not completely jump on the band wagon. Let’s remember, trailers are meant to make movies look spectacular and there are way too many examples of trailers looking awesome and the movies sucking donkey dong!!! But with that said I am definitely excited to see this movie!
EditNinja
EditNinja - 2/24/2011, 2:30 PM
Too often we're spoilt for choice with 3 default opinion-options: LOVE - HATE - MEH. Unfortunately, none of these options require deep thought or analysis.

Hell, it wouldn't surprise me if it ends up being more popular than Green Lantern.

Nice editorial, BTW.
marvel72
marvel72 - 2/24/2011, 2:30 PM
it ain't changed my mind,its an insult to the source material.

the trailer confirmed that for me.
Xandera
Xandera - 2/24/2011, 2:30 PM
HA HA HA TEABAG!!!!
Ven0m
Ven0m - 2/24/2011, 2:32 PM
You werent wrong with your first article bud. Justify it to yourself all you want this movie will blow.
SmokinIndo
SmokinIndo - 2/24/2011, 2:33 PM
@JoshW

I've never been the biggest X-Men fan, but I can understand why people would be frustrated with the creative liberties that Fox has taken with these films. That being said, what was so bad about Ian McKellen's Magneto? Was it his age? To be perfectly honest, if Magneto lived during the Holocaust then I would expect him to look as old as he was portrayed in the movies. The reason I ask why you didn't like him in the first three films was because I always thought that Magneto, Professor X, and the relationship between the two was the one thing that Fox nailed absolutely perfectly.
Ranger14
Ranger14 - 2/24/2011, 2:33 PM
I haven't said the movie is gong to be crap. I am just not interested in the movie because of everything I know of it to date. I am not interested in going back to the past and seeing the "love story" between Magneto and Xavier. I am not interested in seeing teeny Xmen. I am not interested in hearing Cyclops isn't in First Class because he would be too young, but his younger brother plays a part in the movie. Simply not interested in their lack of continuity, which they said they would have to make this a legitimate prequel. They're just going to start the Xmen over again folks, this is just a way to try to not make it look like a reboot. Maybe a rental for me.
patriautism
patriautism - 2/24/2011, 2:34 PM
The worst CBM ever is still and will always remain, David Hasselhoff's made for tv movie, Nick Fury: Agent of Shield.. I still love it though!!

TheUnHasseled
TheUnHasseled - 2/24/2011, 2:34 PM
these "EDITORIAL's" are f*#ing retarded... seriously...

"Why I was wrong for calling a movie terrible before it came out."
"Why I won't see a movie opening weekend based on a 2min trailer."
"Is this random rumor an actual fact that means that this theory I just made up is the plot of a movie."
"Why this movie will be terrible b/c the 30 second teaser didn't sell me."

Editorials are typically supposed to represent the views of the entire publication they're represented within... not one random fanboy who wants to [female dog]... you guys need to learn the difference between an informed opinion piece and gut-reaction fanboy rants based on 30-second television spots and speculation...
Xandera
Xandera - 2/24/2011, 2:36 PM
Feel better after that Hissy Fit TheUnHasseledHoff?
Illuminatus
Illuminatus - 2/24/2011, 2:36 PM
Whats the point of this article? You changed your opinion, zip a dee do da. I normally like your stuff Josh, but why is this front page news? And a trailer, some interviews with cast members, and some lame ass set photos are what changed your mind? Hmm..
CherryBomb
CherryBomb - 2/24/2011, 2:39 PM

I'm really excited for this!
It may deviate from the comics, but I love the casting. (:
MarkCassidy
MarkCassidy - 2/24/2011, 2:40 PM
Ah Josh, I never say I told you so..;) hehe, just kiddin. I respect that you have the stones to change your mind about it.
TheUnHasseled
TheUnHasseled - 2/24/2011, 2:41 PM
i wouldn't categorize it as a hissy fit, but i feel better yes. that is a post based on many many weeks of reading frustrating "editorials" based on speculatory reactions. i think it would be interesting if anyone who posts things like "______ Movie is going to suck" is held accountable when the film comes out and they actually like it, or they just weren't allowed to see it period.

the fact of the matter is... you guys have no clue how the movie is going to turn out... and you're still going to go see it... or download it and watch it.
TheUnHasseled
TheUnHasseled - 2/24/2011, 2:43 PM
@Illuminatus... my point exactly... this is not front page news... who cares if Josh W. is going to see any movie?

you basically showed the idiocy of your last editorial by posting that you were wrong...
luckylu
luckylu - 2/24/2011, 2:49 PM
@tea- exactly. i knew not to go see electra, ghostrider, or punisher war zone. and i know not to see this one. like marvel 72 said- its a slap in the face to the source material
MisterJay
MisterJay - 2/24/2011, 2:57 PM
u bunch of loosers...whit nothing to do but critice things that u can't even dream to make it better..... wait the movie is released....then u can talk your shit....damm...ima character designer...i said the movie could be good... and the prejudge is a double side sword....so i hope they shut your mouth and give a good movie ...why not....:/ just wait to see it... bunch of nerdy, non xperts critics xD
Illuminatus
Illuminatus - 2/24/2011, 2:59 PM
@Joker13 How do you know we arent "critics"? You dont know any of us, dont make the assumption. And by the way, if youre coming on this site, youre just as much a nerd as we are.
1 2 3 4
View Recorder